“Final sprint for all the players”

Bent Christensen is in charge of project management in the offshore business at Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy. (Photo: Siemens Gamesa)
Bent Christensen is in charge of project management in the offshore business at Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy. (Photo: Siemens Gamesa)

Siemens Gamesa is using no less than eight innovative technologies for the pilot project Nissum Bredning Vind. Offshore Wind Industry spoke to Bent Christensen about the rapid pace of development in the industry.

OWI: Hardly a large trade fair goes by without Siemens Gamesa presenting a product innovation for the offshore wind sector. How do you perceive the innovation pressure for Siemens Gamesa?

Bent Christensen: We are not alone with this pressure: The entire offshore industry is running through a rapid development to meet cost-out targets. With the low bids for projects in Denmark and the Netherlands and zero-bids for German projects, this race has been further accelerated. But we are also proud to drive a technology with such an outstanding success story in fast development.

OWI: Has the pressure changed in recent years?

Christensen: Some years ago, we set ourselves ambitious cost-out targets with an LCoE of 10 ct/kWh by 2020, and now we are running ahead of this goal. The momentum in offshore wind is driven by new opportunities and options that are discovered with every milestone we reach. In this context, the most important change in recent years was the awareness that we have now really arrived in the league of main technologies for the future energy supply.

OWI: What impact does competition have on the pace of development?

Christensen: The consolidation processes of the last years clearly show that a certain size is vital to survive in this competitive environment. Only a highly industrialised company will be able to overcome the challenges of the changing market environment. There will also be a highly competitive situation in the future – but the number of players is decreasing. Also the market regimes in several European countries with auction models are a strong trigger for cost reduction through innovations. Now that we see offshore wind becoming a central energy source in only a few years ahead of us, this is a kind of final sprint for all the players in the market. So my prediction for the next decade is that we will have to keep up the pace of development that we are currently seeing.

OWI: Siemens stopped the sale of the 7-MW plant in favour of the 8-MW plant last year, before the first 7 MW plant had even been built. New products are launched on the market before existing ones can deliver long-term experience. Isn’t that an immense risk on the technical side?

Christensen: First of all our customers can select the best turbine for their site specific wind conditions between all ratings of our Direct-Drive Offshore platform. In addition to comprehensive testing, this platform strategy is precisely what ensures the reliability of our products. By retaining most of the components and improving what is necessary to enhance the output, we make sure that the long term experience is incorporated in the genetic code of our products. That is how we connect innovation and evolution in our product development.

OWI: Wouldn’t it be more effective in the end to do fewer but higher jumps?

Christensen: No, there is a learning curve but not a learning staircase for this kind of technological development. Supply chain, substructures, logistics, installation processes and many more elements involved in building and operating offshore wind projects must grow in a synchronised manner. The steps we currently take in higher-rated offshore wind turbines allow the entire industry to mitigate risks and develop by learning.

OWI: In the Nissum Bredning Project, Siemens wants to test new technologies. Which turbine will we see used there?

Christensen: We will install the first serial-built SWT-7.0-154, but this is only one part of the project’s innovations: It will be installed on our gravity jacket foundation that can be assembled with standard steel pipes and robot-welded nodes. The design can be seen as a universal toolkit to build jacket foundations for different water depths.

OWI: Are foundation manufacturers so behind in the area of innovations that Siemens as a turbine manufacturer must also be active in this field?

Christensen: This is not meant as criticism of the colleagues at the foundation manufacturers but rather as a proposal for future concepts. Since the turbine counts for less than 30 percent of the offshore wind LCoE, it is quite natural that we also take other elements of the supply chain into consideration. At Nissum Bredning we will also be using our cable-in-pipe concept, which allows us to use cheaper onshore cables by placing them in plastic pipes. But this is not an attack on cable suppliers, we are simply testing a new idea.

OWI: The foundations of the Danish wind park Vindeby, which was the first offshore wind farm in the world, are currently being disassembled. As one of the original turbine suppliers, how satisfied are you when you look back on the project?

Christensen: This project makes us all very proud. With 25 years in operation, Vindeby has shown proof that offshore wind is reliable and sustainable. In the meantime we have learned so much, we have improved our technology and provide turbines that are nearly 20 times larger in rating and size. But the first experiences we gained with this first commercial offshore park are still in our minds when we do our work. 

OWI: What is the most important lesson learned for you?

Christensen: That the codes and standards used for the design of main components, corrosion protection and so on were sufficient. The turbines were designed for a service life of 20 years, and they were in operation for more than 25 years with high reliability.

OWI: With the decommissioning of Vindeby, the offshore wind industry is once again breaking new ground. How is Siemens Gamesa involved in this process?

Christensen: After decommissioning, we will have a closer look at the condition of the main components after 25 years of wear and tear to see what we can learn to help to optimise current components.

The interview was conducted by Katharina Garus

Pilot project Nissum Bredning Vind

Although the economic prospects of offshore wind energy are now very good, the industry is working tirelessly on innovations, among other things in the pilot project Nissum Bredning Vind. Siemens Gamesa is not only supplying four SWT-7.0-154 wind turbines but also new types of jacket foundations, towers and a 66-kV internal cabling for the 28-MW project on the north-west coast of Denmark.

Siemens Gamesa hopes to achieve the most significant cost savings, 40%, by using its new Gravity Jacket Foundation. It consists of standard steel tubes, whose connection nodes are to be manufactured in large series by welding robots in the future. This will allow inexpensive foundations for different water depths to be built using a modular system.

A transition piece (TP) made of concrete is placed on the foundation. The transition pieces will be poured at the installation port. The heavy weight of the concrete TPs dampens vibrations in the entire carrying structure and allows further savings: the Slender Towers, which are also being tested at Nissum Bredning, have thinner walls than conventional towers and get by with less steel.

Further innovations will be tested in the area of cabling. The cables will have a capacity of 66 kV instead of 33 kV. This saves a lot of copper. Siemens Gamesa estimates that the cost savings due to the higher voltage will be up to 15%. "This upgrade may seem like a small step toward lowering electricity generation costs, but we believe it will be a standard in the future because the benefits will increase with increasing project and turbine size," said Peter Esmann, Product Manager at Division Wind Power and Renewables at Siemens Gamesa. A ‘cable in pipe’ solution will also simplify cabling at Nissum Bredning. Less expensive onshore cables will be laid inside of plastic pipes for this purpose.

The installation work for Nissum Bredning has begun and commissioning is planned for the autumn.

Katharina Garus


Similar Entries

Assela Wind Farm (pict. Siemens Gamesa)

Siemens Gamesa has signed its first wind power project in Ethiopia with state-owned electricity company Ethiopian Electric Power (EEP), strengthening its leadership in Africa as the country begins to expand its green energy capacity to meet ambitious renewable targets.

Using Bolt-Check to monitor clamp load (pict.: R&D A/S)

The Bolt-Check tool reduces preventative maintenance time, resulting in service cost reductions while maximizing uptime; Reduced health and safety costs.

Webinar "Operation of Wind Power Plants in Cold Climate 2021" (pict. VGB)

For the first time the results of the VGB Research Project “Comparison of blade-based ice detection systems” will be presented at the webinar
"Operation of Wind Power Plants in Cold Climate".

Ebee Smart Technologies GmbH and The Mobility House are coordinating the interoperability of their systems. A smooth interaction between the Ebee solution, the charging controller from Bender, which has been verified by thousands of test cases, and the Charging and Energy Management system ChargePilot from The Mobility House is guaranteed.